Skip to content

535 Final forecast · Nov 3
Dispatches

More

Back to Senate

Idaho Senate

Projected winner

Jim Risch (R)

civicAPI ·

713,281 reported votes
Jim RischRepublican
402,983
Todd AchillesIndependent
239,422
Natalie M FlemingIndependent
50,134
Matt LoesbyLibertarian
20,742

civicAPI vote report ·

Final forecast

  • Jim Risch (Rep · incumbent)
  • Todd Achilles (Ind)

Favors Rep

Republicans100%

Unchanged over the past week.

Republicans are favored, winning 99,959 of 100,000 simulated elections.

Favors Rep

Republicans100%

Unchanged over the past week.

Republicans are favored, winning 100,000 of 100,000 simulated elections.

Includes partisan internals. The published forecast is R 100%.

Estimated margin
R+27.9
5th–95th interval
R+41.7 to R+14.2
Estimated margin
R+25.8
5th–95th interval
R+33.5 to R+18.0

Win probability over time With partisan internals

Republicans: 100% in the latest run, between 99% and 100% since Aug 16, 2026.Republicans: 100% in the latest run, between 99% and 100% since Aug 16, 2026.

Dem win probability Rep win probability Tossup band

Polls

Ind-leaning poll Rep-leaning poll Partisan-sponsored, not in average current average: R+14.2

Filters this polling table only. Forecast values and scatter-chart data remain unchanged. Choose All matchups to restore every group.

Showing 13 polls across all matchups.

Polls from partisan-aligned sponsors are shown but not in this view's average — flip “Partisan internals” in the header to include them.Partisan-sponsored polls are in this view's average, shifted 1.4 points toward the non-sponsor party and given half weight — methodology.

Pollster Dates Sample Results Margin House adj. Source
James Risch (R) vs Todd Achilles (I) · 4 polls
VoteNexus ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Oct 21–Oct 22, 2026 700 lv James Risch 49.0% Todd Achilles 43.0% R+6.0 None Source: VoteNexus, Oct 21–Oct 22, 2026
The Bullfinch Group ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Aug 4–Aug 7, 2026 608 lv James E. Risch 33.0% Todd Achilles 38.0% I+5.0 I+3.9 D+1.1 lean removed Source: The Bullfinch Group, Aug 4–Aug 7, 2026
The Bullfinch Group ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted May 29–Jun 1, 2026 774 rv James E. Risch 40.0% Todd Achilles 36.0% R+4.0 R+5.1 D+1.1 lean removed Source: The Bullfinch Group, May 29–Jun 1, 2026
Public Policy Polling ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Mar 16–Mar 17, 2026 639 rv James E. Risch 48.0% Todd Achilles 34.0% R+14.0 R+12.5 R+1.5 lean removed Source: Public Policy Polling, Mar 16–Mar 17, 2026
James Risch (R) vs Matt Loesby (LIB) vs Todd Achilles (I) · 5 polls
Peak Insights rep sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Oct 13–Oct 15, 2026 500 lv James Risch 54.0% Natalie Fleming 3.0% Todd Achilles 27.0% Matt Loesby 2.0% R+27.0 None Source: Peak Insights, Oct 13–Oct 15, 2026
Peak Insights rep sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Sep 28–Sep 30, 2026 500 lv James Risch 49.0% Natalie Fleming 3.0% Todd Achilles 24.0% Matt Loesby 2.0% R+25.0 None Source: Peak Insights, Sep 28–Sep 30, 2026
Peak Insights rep sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Aug 11–Aug 13, 2026 500 lv James E. Risch 52.0% Natalie Fleming 9.0% Todd Achilles 18.0% Matt Loesby 2.0% R+34.0 None Source: Peak Insights, Aug 11–Aug 13, 2026
The Bullfinch Group ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Aug 4–Aug 7, 2026 608 lv James E. Risch 34.0% Todd Achilles 30.0% Matt Loesby 4.0% R+4.0 R+5.1 D+1.1 lean removed Source: The Bullfinch Group, Aug 4–Aug 7, 2026
Change Research ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Jul 28–Jul 30, 2026 n/a lv James E. Risch 43.0% Natalie Fleming 8.0% Todd Achilles 21.0% Matt Loesby 2.0% R+22.0 R+22.6 D+0.6 lean removed Source: Change Research, Jul 28–Jul 30, 2026
David Roth (D) vs James E. Risch (R) vs Matt Loesby (LIB) vs Todd Achilles (I) · 2 polls
Change Research ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Jul 28–Jul 30, 2026 n/a lv David Roth 13.0% James E. Risch 42.0% Natalie Fleming 3.0% Todd Achilles 18.0% Matt Loesby 1.0% R+24.0 R+24.6 D+0.6 lean removed Source: Change Research, Jul 28–Jul 30, 2026
Peak Insights rep sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted Jun 6–Jun 7, 2026 500 lv David Roth 15.0% James E. Risch 55.0% Natalie Fleming 5.0% Todd Achilles 7.0% Matt Loesby 2.0% R+48.0 None Source: Peak Insights, Jun 6–Jun 7, 2026
David Roth (D) vs James E. Risch (R) vs Todd Achilles (I) · 1 poll
The Bullfinch Group ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted May 29–Jun 1, 2026 774 rv David Roth 15.0% James E. Risch 41.0% Todd Achilles 18.0% R+23.0 R+24.1 D+1.1 lean removed Source: The Bullfinch Group, May 29–Jun 1, 2026
David Roth (D) vs James E. Risch (R) · 1 poll
The Bullfinch Group ind sponsor Not in averageIn average, adjusted May 29–Jun 1, 2026 774 rv David Roth 33.0% James E. Risch 50.0% — None Source: The Bullfinch Group, May 29–Jun 1, 2026

Dispatches about this race

Poll reaction Oct 23, 2026

A Risch-posted Idaho poll nudges our margin a tenth of a point

A Peak Insights survey showing Jim Risch at 54 percent left our odds unchanged and moved our projected margin from R+28.1 to R+28.2.

A new Peak Insights survey of 500 likely voters in Idaho, fielded October 13-15, puts Republican Sen. Jim Risch at 54 percent. The survey reports the independent candidate at 3 percent and other candidates at 2 percent. The poll was posted at senatorrisch.com, the incumbent's own site.

The...

Read the full dispatch →

Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5

Poll reaction Oct 23, 2026

A PAC-sponsored Idaho poll shows a 6-point race, and our forecast barely moves

The VoteNexus survey puts Jim Risch ahead of Todd Achilles by far less than our model expects, yet our Idaho margin shifted by a tenth of a point.

A VoteNexus survey of 700 likely voters, fielded October 21-22 and sponsored by Knock Every Door PAC, finds Republican Sen. Jim Risch at 49% and independent Todd Achilles at 43%. That is a 6-point gap. The poll's results were published via a Google Drive file.

Our forecast did not change in any...

Read the full dispatch →

Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5

Poll reaction Oct 2, 2026

A new Idaho poll leaves our Risch forecast exactly where it was

A Peak Insights survey puts Risch at 49 percent, and our model's average margin holds at R+28.5 after moving in each of our last several Idaho updates.

A Peak Insights survey of 500 likely voters, fielded September 28-30, puts Republican Sen. Jim Risch at 49 percent. The independent line is at 3 percent and other candidates at 2 percent. The poll does not name the independent candidate. Its published results account for 54 percent of respondents...

Read the full dispatch →

Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5