Our Idaho margin widens again while the odds stay pinned
Two August surveys of the Risch–Achilles race disagree by 30 points, and our mean margin moved from R+23.5 to R+30.2 without changing the probability.
Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5 · August 31, 2026 at 4:32 PM EDT
Correction: the forecasts in this article predate a polling-data repair. Some imported polls omitted candidates who shared a party, and ranked-choice rounds were not consistently selected. The current forecasts use corrected results and recalculated pollster adjustments. See current forecasts.
The two most recent polls of Idaho's Senate race point in different directions. A Peak Insights survey of 500 likely voters, fielded August 11-13, put Republican incumbent Jim Risch at 52 percent, with 9 percent for an independent and 2 percent for other candidates. A Bullfinch Group survey of 608 likely voters, fielded August 4-7, had Risch at 34 percent and independent Todd Achilles at 30 percent, with 4 percent for others — close, on a sample that size, rather than a lead.
Our model now puts the mean margin at R+30.2, out from R+23.5 in the previous run earlier this afternoon. The 5th-to-95th percentile band runs from R+48.7 to R+11.2, wider on the Republican side than the R+33.9 to R+12.8 range it replaced. The probability did not move: our model gives Risch a 100 percent chance and the Democratic column a 0 in 100 chance, unchanged.
The rest of the Idaho data is older and no more settled. The Bullfinch Group's May 29 to June 1 poll of 774 registered voters had Risch 40, Achilles 36 in a head-to-head; the same sample gave Risch 50 to 33 against a generic Democrat, and 41-18-15 in a three-way with Achilles and a Democrat. A Public Policy Polling survey of 639 registered voters, fielded March 16-17, had Risch 48, Achilles 34. Spreads across those five results range from four points to 17.
Nationally, our model has the generic ballot at D+6.5 across 28 polls in a 45-day window. It gives Democrats a 49 percent chance of Senate control and Republicans 50 percent, with a mean of 50.2 Democratic seats against the 51 Democrats need; Republicans need 50, because a 50-50 tie goes to them on the vice president's vote. Idaho is not among the seats that decide that.
Polls this dispatch was written from
- Peak Insights · Aug 13, 2026 · n=500 · Idaho Senate
- The Bullfinch Group · Aug 7, 2026 · n=608 · Idaho Senate
- The Bullfinch Group · Jun 1, 2026 · n=774 · Idaho Senate
- The Bullfinch Group · Jun 1, 2026 · n=774 · Idaho Senate
- The Bullfinch Group · Jun 1, 2026 · n=774 · Idaho Senate
- Public Policy Polling · Mar 17, 2026 · n=639 · Idaho Senate
Every constant behind these numbers is on the methodology page.