Siena poll of PA-8 moves our forecast a bit further toward Bresnahan
A New York Times/Siena survey shows a close race, and our model now gives Paige Cognetti 83 percent odds, down from 87 percent earlier today.
Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 · October 25, 2026 at 6:03 AM EDT
Correction: the forecasts in this article predate a polling-data repair. Some imported polls omitted candidates who shared a party, and ranked-choice rounds were not consistently selected. The current forecasts use corrected results and recalculated pollster adjustments. See current forecasts.
A New York Times/Siena University survey of 402 likely voters in Pennsylvania's 8th District, fielded October 16-22 for The Philadelphia Inquirer, found Democrat Paige Cognetti at 50.5 percent and Republican Rep. Rob Bresnahan at 46.5 percent. That is a gap of about four points in a modest sample, and the race in this poll is close.
Our model now gives Cognetti an 83 in 100 chance of winning the seat, down from 87 percent in the run completed at 4:32 a.m. ET today. Our projected margin moved from D+8.6 to D+7.2. The poll showed a narrower race than our model had expected, so it pulled the estimate toward Bresnahan. It did not change which candidate our model favors. This is the second recent update to move in that direction.
The spread of plausible outcomes remains wide. Our model's 5th-to-95th percentile range runs from R+5.4 to D+19.8, compared with R+4.1 to D+21.1 before the new poll. A Bresnahan win sits inside that range, and our model puts his chance at 17 percent.
Nationally, our generic ballot average stands at D+8.5 across 39 polls from the past 45 days. Our model gives Democrats a 99 percent chance of winning a House majority, with a mean of 245.9 Democratic seats against the 218 needed. That figure is somewhat firmer than it should be: our simulation correlates error nationally, by census division, by state and by district, but it does not link demographically similar districts in different places, because we lack the data to do so.
Polls this dispatch was written from
- The New York Times/Siena University · Oct 22, 2026 · n=402 · PA-8
Every constant behind these numbers is on the methodology page.