New ID-2 poll leaves our forecast for Simpson unchanged
A PAC-sponsored VoteNexus survey shows Mike Simpson ahead by 15 points, close to the margin our model already expected in Idaho's 2nd District.
Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 · October 23, 2026 at 4:03 PM EDT
Correction: the forecasts in this article predate a polling-data repair. Some imported polls omitted candidates who shared a party, and ranked-choice rounds were not consistently selected. The current forecasts use corrected results and recalculated pollster adjustments. See current forecasts.
A new poll in Idaho's 2nd District did not move our forecast. Our model gives Elinor Gilbreath, the Democrat, a 1 in 100 chance of defeating Republican incumbent Mike Simpson. That is the same estimate our model produced in its previous run earlier today.
The poll, conducted by VoteNexus for the Knock Every Door PAC among likely voters and fielded October 21-22, puts Simpson at 46% and Gilbreath at 31%. An independent option drew 5% and other candidates 2%, leaving roughly 16% of respondents with no stated preference. We do not have a sample size or margin of error for the survey. It was sponsored by a political action committee, and readers should weigh it accordingly.
The poll's 15-point gap is somewhat narrower than our model's average expected margin of R+19.3, which did not change with this run. Our model's 5th-to-95th percentile range now runs from R+32.0 to R+6.5, compared with R+32.0 to R+6.6 before. That shift is negligible. Even the most Democratic end of that range has Simpson winning comfortably.
Nationally, our model gives Democrats a 99% chance of winning a House majority, with an average of 246.1 Democratic seats against the 218 needed. Our generic ballot average stands at D+8.5 across 39 polls. That national environment does not reach into ID-2 in our simulations. The House figure carries a known limitation of our own. Our simulation correlates error nationally, by census division, by state and by district, but not across demographically similar districts in different places, so the control probability is marginally firmer than it would otherwise be. The election is 11 days away.
Polls this dispatch was written from
- VoteNexus · Oct 22, 2026 · ID-2
Every constant behind these numbers is on the methodology page.