A close AZ-1 poll trims Shah's edge in our forecast
One FirstStrategic survey showing a tight race moved our model's estimate of Amish Shah's chance from 80% to 76%, with Shah still favored over Jay Feely.
Written by the newsroom · anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 · October 6, 2026 at 10:02 AM EDT
Correction: the forecasts in this article predate a polling-data repair. Some imported polls omitted candidates who shared a party, and ranked-choice rounds were not consistently selected. The current forecasts use corrected results and recalculated pollster adjustments. See current forecasts.
A FirstStrategic Communications and Public Affairs survey of 400 registered voters in Arizona's 1st District, fielded October 1, found Democrat Amish Shah at 44.4% and Republican Jay Feely at 41.6%. That 2.8-point gap is small for a sample of that size. The poll shows a close race, not a clear lead for either candidate.
The poll moved our forecast modestly. Our model now gives Shah a 76 in 100 chance of winning the seat, down from 80% in our run earlier this morning. Feely's chance rose from 20% to 24%. Our model's expected margin narrowed from D+6.9 to D+6.0.
The new numbers adjusted our estimate rather than overturning it. Shah remains favored in our model, and the poll's margin is narrower than our model's expected margin. Our model's range of plausible outcomes is wide. Its 5th-to-95th percentile range now runs from R+7.8 to D+19.7, compared with R+6.9 to D+20.7 before. A Feely win sits comfortably inside that range.
Nationally, our model gives Democrats a 99% chance of winning a House majority, which takes 218 seats, with a mean of 245 Democratic seats. That figure is somewhat firmer than it should be. Our simulation correlates error nationally, by census division, by state and by district. It does not yet link demographically similar districts in different parts of the country, because we lack the data to do so.
Polls this dispatch was written from
- FirstStrategic Communications and Public Affairs · Oct 1, 2026 · n=400 · AZ-1
Every constant behind these numbers is on the methodology page.